How to Decide Between a Shower Remodel or Replacement
Before diving into your bathroom project, it’s important to assess how much work your shower update will actually require. The design you choose, such as a modern walk-in shower, tub-shower combo or a custom tile shower, will dictate whether you’ll need a full renovation or a simple replacement.
Understanding the difference between the two can help you plan more effectively, set a realistic budget, and avoid unnecessary delays. In this blog, we’ll explore the key differences, cost factors, and what to expect as you move through this process.
What to Expect from a Complete Shower Remodel
A shower remodel is a comprehensive upgrade that changes the structure, layout, or location of your shower. This is ideal when you’re rethinking your space entirely—such as switching from a tub to a modern walk-in shower or incorporating a new plumbing layout.
Remodels often require contractors, plumbers, electricians, and design experts. While it takes more time, a remodel gives you full freedom to reimagine your bathroom from top to bottom, including:
- Installing new tiles
- Moving the drain
- Integrating high-end designs
Shower Replacements: Upgrades That Make a Big Difference
A shower replacement updates the look and function of your existing shower without requiring major demolition or plumbing work. It’s a great choice for homeowners who are happy with their current layout but want a more modern design or improved features.
For homeowners researching how to install a shower quickly, this approach offers an efficient upgrade without the hassle of a full bathroom renovation.
With KOHLER® LuxStone®, you can get a brand-new shower installed in as little as a day. No grout lines, no delays. Just a clean, stylish finish with minimal disruption to your routine.
Modern Shower Styles to Consider
Walk-In Showers
A popular choice for homeowners seeking comfort and accessibility, walk-in showers eliminate the need to step over a high tub wall. They’re customizable with a range of
modern shower wall styles, stylish glass doors, and safety features like built-in seating and grab bars.
Bathtub-Shower Combos
If your household needs the flexibility of a bath and a shower, a modern bathtub-shower combo might be your best bet. Add sleek sliding glass doors and upgraded fixtures with LuxStone wall designs to create a space that’s both functional and sophisticated.
Key Differences Between a Remodel and a Replacement
Demolition & Installation
- A remodel often includes demolition, plumbing changes, and structural repairs.
- A replacement involves removing the old unit and installing a new one—fast and efficient.
Plumbing Adjustments
- Want to relocate your shower or add multiple sprays? That requires a remodel.
- Are you keeping your shower in the same location? A replacement simplifies the process and minimizes plumbing work.
Structural Repairs
- If you’re experiencing soft spots or damage to your shower floor, a remodel might be necessary to fix the issue at its source.
- A replacement can refresh your space cosmetically but won’t address deeper structural problems.
Drain Repositioning
- Remodeling allows for full drain and pipe repositioning.
- Replacement lets you choose between left, center, or right-drain bases—without moving pipes.
What’s the Cost to Install a New Shower?
The cost to install a new shower depends on several factors:
- Scope of the remodel or replacement
- Material and fixture choices
- Plumbing or structural changes
- Your preferred modern shower design
On average, replacements are more budget-friendly and faster to complete. Remodels offer more customization but may involve higher labor and material costs. KOHLER LuxStone can help you determine the best path forward for your space and budget.
Which Option Is Right for You?
If you’re looking to change your shower layout, style, and function, a remodel may be the right choice. For a faster upgrade that still delivers lasting results, a KOHLER LuxStone shower replacement is a smart solution.
Whichever path you choose, you’ll enjoy a beautiful, durable shower that enhances your everyday routine.
Start Your Shower Transformation
KOHLER LuxStone makes it simple! A KOHLER Authorized Dealer will provide a free in-home consultation and quote to help you determine the best approach based on your space, style, and goals.
Contact us today to schedule your free estimate and bring your shower vision to life—with expert installation, premium materials, and modern design that lasts.
