If you’re remodeling your bathroom, one of the decisions you’ll eventually need to make is choosing between a shower insert and custom-built walls. Each option has its pros and cons, and what works best really depends on your space, budget, and how involved you want the project to be.
In this guide, we’ll walk through the key differences between the two—how they perform, what they cost, and what kind of maintenance to expect—so you can choose what makes the most sense for your home.
What Are Shower Inserts?
Shower inserts, also known as shower surrounds or prefabricated shower kits, are factory-made units designed for easy installation. Typically constructed from acrylic, fiberglass, or composite materials, these inserts come as one-piece or multi-piece systems that fit directly into your existing shower or tub alcove.
Key Features of Shower Inserts
- Prefabricated panels for walls, and often a matching shower base
- Standardized sizes to fit most bathrooms
- Relatively quick installation
- More budget-friendly compared to custom solutions
What Are Custom Shower Walls?
Custom shower walls are built to your specifications, offering more flexibility in layout, features, and aesthetics. Materials can include engineered stone, tile, glass, or solid surface panels.
Key Features of Custom Shower Walls
- Made-to-measure panels or tiles for a perfect fit
- Wide range of materials and finishes
- Numerous design aesthetics from Classic to Modern styles
- Endless patterns and colors
- With brands like KOHLER, you can expect quick and efficient installation—often completed in as little as one to two days.
- Professional installation required for most systems, which typically requires a greater upfront cost but also allows for longer-term value
Comparing Cost, Durability, and Long-Term Value
Shower Inserts: Budget-Friendly but Limited Longevity
Shower inserts are a cost-effective solution, thanks to their prefabricated design and quick installation and are ideal for budget-conscious remodels. However, they may not offer the same durability or return on investment as custom options. Lower-cost materials can be more prone to scratching, discoloration, or cracking over time.
- Average Cost: Lower upfront investment
- Installation: Fast and straightforward
- Durability & Long-Term Value: May show wear over time; less likely to enhance resale value compared to custom options
Engineered, Crushed Stone Shower Walls: Higher Investment with Lasting Value
Engineered stone options like KOHLER LuxStone are nonporous, stain-resistant, and highly durable—ideal for long-term use. With minimal upkeep, these walls retain their look and performance for years and can significantly increase your home’s value.
- Average Cost: Higher upfront investment than other options but with greater potential return
- Installation: Installation time varies, but companies like KOHLER provide installation in as little as a day.
- Durability & Long-Term Value: Built to last with premium materials; enhances both everyday experience and resale appeal
KOHLER LuxStone: A Custom Wall Solution
KOHLER LuxStone offers both durability and design flexibility. Made from nonporous engineered stone, LuxStone panels are built to resist stains, mold, and mildew—making them as practical as they are beautiful.
Why Choose KOHLER LuxStone?
- Custom sizing and design options
- Grout-free design for a streamlined look
- Professional installation in as little as a day
- Lifetime Limited Warranty for peace of mind
Making the Smart Choice for Your Home
Choosing between a shower insert and a custom wall system can significantly influence the outcome of your remodel.
If you’re looking for a stylish, hassle-free upgrade with long-lasting quality, KOHLER LuxStone is the perfect solution. Schedule your free design consultation today and take the first step toward transforming your shower into a space you’ll love!
